"This might be the most important and prominent piece of paranormal history in the world," he said of the Connecticut house and occult museum.

There have been attempts to tour the museum’s contents to keep the show rolling on—including one supported by a viral hoax that claimed Annabelle had gone missing a few years back—but Rife and Castee apparently intend to bring the collection back to life.

Matt Rife is now the legal guardian of the late Ed and Lorraine Warren’s Occult Museum.